Review of My Gold by NazGhuL:
Overall Gameplay (5.5/14 pts)
- Player Experience (3.5/8 pts)
- Quality of Mechanics (2/6 pts)
Comments: The concept was interesting and unique. But I had 4 different potions, and I never fully understood what any of them actually did (aside from the first one turning rocks into gold). So when I had to fend off zombies, I simply spammed potions of all types until they died (made possible by the fact that there was no cooldown). I got to the point in the game where zombies were spawning so fast that I was simply a full-time potion spammer until I got bored and quit.
Farthest I got was 2000 out of 3000 gold, and all of that ground was made in about the first minute and a half.
Theme Inclusion (6/7 pts)
Comments: There seemed to be some interesting reactions between vials, which fits nicely under 'chemical reactions'.
Overall Presentation (4.5/9 pts)
- Menus/Interfaces (1.5/3 pts)
- Quality of Graphics (1/3 pts)
- Quality of Audio (2/3 pts)
Comments: The GUI could use some work, but the instructions screen was nice. Lots of room for improvement with the graphics. The audio was good but the music needed a bit more color and the sound effects a bit more variation.
No penalties assessed.
Final Comments: I liked the concept you had going - the execution was just a bit off. Mostly I just didn't know what any of the potions did.
TOTAL SCORE: 16 / 30 PTS